The plan isn't all it's cracked up to be. There are several issues on both the homeowner and investor side as well as the lender and builder side that make this plan problematic in the long term. As the Economic Advisor for Vice President Biden said yesterday, we will "share the pain" -- we being the government and the banks.She details the perverse incentives that only a government could devise: Incentivising people to quit their jobs and quit paying their mortgages to qualify for government assistance, not to mention those underwater who are scooping up a new property at firesale prices and then abandoning the old home. Professor Babb's article is an excellent argument against this plan. Arm yourself. Go read the entire article here.
There is only one problem -- "we" are the taxpayers, and of those that own homes, over 90% of them are still paying on time. It seems like the "Ask not what your country can do for you..." idiom doesn't apply to everyone. The plan won't work. It doesn't address jumbo mortgages, many of which are about to reset this year and through 2011 and don't qualify for Freddie or Fannie mortgages.
It doesn't address the moral hazard of so many people I read about and hear from that are literally not paying their mortgage, but instead are waiting for a government handout.
It doesn't address those who are frustrated by seeing big banks and the "Big 3" given billions of our taxpayer dollars while they pay their negative amortization mortgage on a home that is $200,000 under water -- homeowners that are now encouraging their spouses to quit their jobs so they can get an even lower payment under the new 31% DTI.
http://www.thestreet.com/print/story/10465005.html
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/chi-rosenthal-23-feb23,0,6124753.story
