Pages

Showing posts with label santayana. Show all posts
Showing posts with label santayana. Show all posts

Monday, December 8, 2008

FDR, Obama, & The Forgotten Man

I'm reading The Forgotten Man, by Amity Shlaes. It is an especially useful book right now since it knocks down many myths of the Great Depression.

The 1929 crash was no different than previous panics, but government intervention made it worse. Hoover's tight-fisted monetary policy, tax hikes, and import tariffs turned a temporary dip into a full-blown depression. FDR's centrally-planned government interventions scared away private money and intimidated investors, prolonging the depression.

Perhaps our government should indeed be spending more money right now in a Keynesian effort to prime the pump. But that only goes so far, and the danger is that government money is stupid money: How does a bureaucrat spend a dollar so it best benefits the economy? How does government avoid competing with the private sector? Or favoring one company over another?

A well-regulated free market is much more efficient. And no, our current economy is neither well-regulated nor efficient: It is a rotten swiss cheese shot though with government intervention, and greedy rats slink through dark warrens carved out by politicians who use our constitution as a doormat. Government should set rules of fair play and then butt out, but there's too much money to be made engaging in mutual backscratching with unions and big business.


Another ignored lesson from 1929 is that raising taxes is a bad idea because it depresses private sector hiring. And government intervention in the free-market creates uncertainty that kills economic growth. Roosevelt didn't pull us out of the Great Depression; the private sector gearing up for World War II did. Roosevelt's policies can be rightly credited with keeping people from starving, but private enterprise rebuilt our economic engine.

George Santayana famously observed that those who do not remember history are doomed to repeat it.

A witty unattributed riposte is: Those who do remember history are doomed to make new, more interesting mistakes.

Well, President-elect Obama's braintrust is all atwitter at the prospect of reliving the good old days, while relishing the opportunity to outdo FDR's ambitious projects.

The big ticket will be the public works spending. “We will create millions of jobs by making the single largest new investment in our national infrastructure since the creation of the federal highway system in the 1950s,” Mr. Obama said.

He did not give any estimate of how much he would devote to that purpose, but when he met with the nation’s governors this week, they said the states had $136 billion worth of already-approved road, bridge and other projects ready to go as soon as funding became available. They estimated each billion dollars spent would create 40,000 jobs.
Providing some economic incentives for the private sector is a good thing, even in the environmental area. But watch out for pointy-headed bureaucrats who want to perform social experiments using our tax dollars:
“We won’t do it the old Washington way,” Mr. Obama said. “We won’t just throw money at the problem. We’ll measure progress by the reforms we make and the results we achieve — by the jobs we create, by the energy we save, by whether America is more competitive in the world.”
This is reassuring to a liberal or moderate ear, but to the conservative, free-market ear it is a clanging alarm bell. The new administration needs to promote job growth and stimulate the economy, but it must not repeat the interventionist, central-planning mistakes of the past.

It's up to us conservatives to know our history and get involved in this discussion. We can't just throw rocks. People are out of work and the economy is on the skids; extraordinary times call for extraordinary measures. Conservatives won't control this debate, but they need to stay in it to fight for free-market solutions. To do otherwise would be to helplessly watch nostalgic old-line Democrats usher in the 1930's all over again.