Can we learn anything from our current economic situation? With Uncle Sam throwing his protective tarp over the investment bankers who got us into this mess, you know those pirates won't learn anything other than, "let's do it again!"
We commoners must be content with nothing but good advice. WikiHow provides us with seven steps for applying lessons from the Great Depression:
1. Stop using credit
2. Nurture positive relationships with family and friends
3. Do it yourself
4. See Frugality as a virtue
5. Treat food with respect
6. Reuse, reuse, reuse
7. Be thankful
Those of us who grew up in a working class family already have these steps emblazoned upon our consciousness. Do it yourself is the only answer for those who have more time than money. As for #5, I learned as a child that wasting food is a sin and calling food "crap" was considered an insult to God that earned swift retribution.
So leave the tarp to the rich and powerful, it'll likely blow away in a windstorm anyway. These effete bankers have probably never heard of bungee cords. We're better off with the advice. It's worth more than all the money that used to be in the US Treasury.
Happy New Year!
Showing posts with label great depression. Show all posts
Showing posts with label great depression. Show all posts
Thursday, January 1, 2009
Monday, December 8, 2008
FDR, Obama, & The Forgotten Man
I'm reading The Forgotten Man, by Amity Shlaes. It is an especially useful book right now since it knocks down many myths of the Great Depression.
The 1929 crash was no different than previous panics, but government intervention made it worse. Hoover's tight-fisted monetary policy, tax hikes, and import tariffs turned a temporary dip into a full-blown depression. FDR's centrally-planned government interventions scared away private money and intimidated investors, prolonging the depression.
Perhaps our government should indeed be spending more money right now in a Keynesian effort to prime the pump. But that only goes so far, and the danger is that government money is stupid money: How does a bureaucrat spend a dollar so it best benefits the economy? How does government avoid competing with the private sector? Or favoring one company over another?
A well-regulated free market is much more efficient. And no, our current economy is neither well-regulated nor efficient: It is a rotten swiss cheese shot though with government intervention, and greedy rats slink through dark warrens carved out by politicians who use our constitution as a doormat. Government should set rules of fair play and then butt out, but there's too much money to be made engaging in mutual backscratching with unions and big business.
Another ignored lesson from 1929 is that raising taxes is a bad idea because it depresses private sector hiring. And government intervention in the free-market creates uncertainty that kills economic growth. Roosevelt didn't pull us out of the Great Depression; the private sector gearing up for World War II did. Roosevelt's policies can be rightly credited with keeping people from starving, but private enterprise rebuilt our economic engine.
George Santayana famously observed that those who do not remember history are doomed to repeat it.
A witty unattributed riposte is: Those who do remember history are doomed to make new, more interesting mistakes.
Well, President-elect Obama's braintrust is all atwitter at the prospect of reliving the good old days, while relishing the opportunity to outdo FDR's ambitious projects.
It's up to us conservatives to know our history and get involved in this discussion. We can't just throw rocks. People are out of work and the economy is on the skids; extraordinary times call for extraordinary measures. Conservatives won't control this debate, but they need to stay in it to fight for free-market solutions. To do otherwise would be to helplessly watch nostalgic old-line Democrats usher in the 1930's all over again.
The 1929 crash was no different than previous panics, but government intervention made it worse. Hoover's tight-fisted monetary policy, tax hikes, and import tariffs turned a temporary dip into a full-blown depression. FDR's centrally-planned government interventions scared away private money and intimidated investors, prolonging the depression.
Perhaps our government should indeed be spending more money right now in a Keynesian effort to prime the pump. But that only goes so far, and the danger is that government money is stupid money: How does a bureaucrat spend a dollar so it best benefits the economy? How does government avoid competing with the private sector? Or favoring one company over another?
A well-regulated free market is much more efficient. And no, our current economy is neither well-regulated nor efficient: It is a rotten swiss cheese shot though with government intervention, and greedy rats slink through dark warrens carved out by politicians who use our constitution as a doormat. Government should set rules of fair play and then butt out, but there's too much money to be made engaging in mutual backscratching with unions and big business.
Another ignored lesson from 1929 is that raising taxes is a bad idea because it depresses private sector hiring. And government intervention in the free-market creates uncertainty that kills economic growth. Roosevelt didn't pull us out of the Great Depression; the private sector gearing up for World War II did. Roosevelt's policies can be rightly credited with keeping people from starving, but private enterprise rebuilt our economic engine.
George Santayana famously observed that those who do not remember history are doomed to repeat it.
A witty unattributed riposte is: Those who do remember history are doomed to make new, more interesting mistakes.
Well, President-elect Obama's braintrust is all atwitter at the prospect of reliving the good old days, while relishing the opportunity to outdo FDR's ambitious projects.
Providing some economic incentives for the private sector is a good thing, even in the environmental area. But watch out for pointy-headed bureaucrats who want to perform social experiments using our tax dollars:The big ticket will be the public works spending. “We will create millions of jobs by making the single largest new investment in our national infrastructure since the creation of the federal highway system in the 1950s,” Mr. Obama said.
He did not give any estimate of how much he would devote to that purpose, but when he met with the nation’s governors this week, they said the states had $136 billion worth of already-approved road, bridge and other projects ready to go as soon as funding became available. They estimated each billion dollars spent would create 40,000 jobs.
“We won’t do it the old Washington way,” Mr. Obama said. “We won’t just throw money at the problem. We’ll measure progress by the reforms we make and the results we achieve — by the jobs we create, by the energy we save, by whether America is more competitive in the world.”This is reassuring to a liberal or moderate ear, but to the conservative, free-market ear it is a clanging alarm bell. The new administration needs to promote job growth and stimulate the economy, but it must not repeat the interventionist, central-planning mistakes of the past.
It's up to us conservatives to know our history and get involved in this discussion. We can't just throw rocks. People are out of work and the economy is on the skids; extraordinary times call for extraordinary measures. Conservatives won't control this debate, but they need to stay in it to fight for free-market solutions. To do otherwise would be to helplessly watch nostalgic old-line Democrats usher in the 1930's all over again.
Labels:
economy,
great depression,
history,
obama,
santayana
Sunday, December 7, 2008
Happy Days Are Here Again
Obama Pledges Massive Public Works Program
The New York Times' giddy, screaming headline says it all. Liberals are partying like it's 1929... Actually, 1932, when disgraced president and former wonder boy Herbert Hoover was driven from office by the election of Franklin Delano Roosevelt. It's all about jobs. Mr. Obama is planning a massive jobs program ala FDR.
Now if we could just find 5.5 million Americans qualified and willing to do construction work. This could turn into a huge boon for illegal immigrants...
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/07/us/politics/07radio.html?_r=1&ref=politics
The New York Times' giddy, screaming headline says it all. Liberals are partying like it's 1929... Actually, 1932, when disgraced president and former wonder boy Herbert Hoover was driven from office by the election of Franklin Delano Roosevelt. It's all about jobs. Mr. Obama is planning a massive jobs program ala FDR.
Mr. Obama and his team are working with Congressional leaders to fashion a spending package that could invest hundreds of billions of dollars into the economy. A big part of that would be infrastructure projects such as building or repairing roads, bridges, schools, sewer systems and other public utilities.If government is hell-bent on blowing a bunch of money, national infrastructure is much preferable to dubious "green jobs," and other lurches into socialist banking experiments. This could produce over 5 million jobs. Real jobs creating real infrastructure that benefits our nation.
The big ticket will be the public works spending. “We will create millions of jobs by making the single largest new investment in our national infrastructure since the creation of the federal highway system in the 1950s,” Mr. Obama said.
Now if we could just find 5.5 million Americans qualified and willing to do construction work. This could turn into a huge boon for illegal immigrants...
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/07/us/politics/07radio.html?_r=1&ref=politics
Labels:
great depression
Wednesday, October 15, 2008
Democrats Nostalgic for the Great Depression
God bless those Democrats. They're so nostalgic. This is not a new Great Depression, but if we all try hard enough, we can make it one!
They long to take us back to yesteryear, when financial collapse ushered in an era of solidarity and equality. We were all in this together. All together in the crapper, but we were all together.
Ah, what a time it was: Hobos huddled around open fires down at the rail yard, bankers were jumping out of windows, and we spent more time at home with family because we had no money to feed our gas-guzzling, smog-belching automobiles. We flocked around radios and hearkened to the voice of a beneficent father figure, worshiping at the feet of Big Government.
Yes, Big Government liberals, who were smarter that we were, made all our decisions for us. And Politico reports that the Totalitarian Trio of Obama, Polosi and Reid have plans to bring back the good ole' days .
We're bad, we're dirty, our carbon footprint is too big. We're racist and fat and too successful. Time to quash this jingoistic belief in American Exceptionalism and remake America to look and act more like the rest of the world...
... Oh, and they want to rescue the United States from the evils of Reaganism, free-market capitalism and conservatism. They blame the current debacle on Republicans to divert attention from the Democratic socialist policies that caused it. To drive a stake through the heart of conservatism and reestablish the dominance of we-say-so liberalism is the real agenda.
It will definitely be a Change. And we'll all be Hoping for an end to it once the nostalgic Democrats' crank up their big government, big spending, big intrusive solutions for every nook and cranny of our lives.
They long to take us back to yesteryear, when financial collapse ushered in an era of solidarity and equality. We were all in this together. All together in the crapper, but we were all together.
Ah, what a time it was: Hobos huddled around open fires down at the rail yard, bankers were jumping out of windows, and we spent more time at home with family because we had no money to feed our gas-guzzling, smog-belching automobiles. We flocked around radios and hearkened to the voice of a beneficent father figure, worshiping at the feet of Big Government.
Yes, Big Government liberals, who were smarter that we were, made all our decisions for us. And Politico reports that the Totalitarian Trio of Obama, Polosi and Reid have plans to bring back the good ole' days .
With visions of a massive liberal majority in the next Congress and the power to remake economic policy for the next generation, Democrats are dusting off their New Deal history books and openly discussing the idea of re-engineering Depression-era agencies for the 21st century.Oh yea, they've got plans! We are not going through a depression, but the Totalitarian Trio will bring us a New Deal solution anyway. They just can't keep their pathological self-loathing to themselves:
Several lawmakers want to bring back the Home Ownership Loan Corp., and others have discussed resurrecting the defunct Reconstruction Finance Corp., a federal program that made direct loans to businesses. Others see a lame-duck stimulus bill less as a short-term cash infusion for the economy and more as a long-term, government-driven jobs creator — a kind of modern Works Progress Administration that invests in infrastructure, bridges and roads.
We're bad, we're dirty, our carbon footprint is too big. We're racist and fat and too successful. Time to quash this jingoistic belief in American Exceptionalism and remake America to look and act more like the rest of the world...
... Oh, and they want to rescue the United States from the evils of Reaganism, free-market capitalism and conservatism. They blame the current debacle on Republicans to divert attention from the Democratic socialist policies that caused it. To drive a stake through the heart of conservatism and reestablish the dominance of we-say-so liberalism is the real agenda.
It will definitely be a Change. And we'll all be Hoping for an end to it once the nostalgic Democrats' crank up their big government, big spending, big intrusive solutions for every nook and cranny of our lives.
Labels:
Democrats,
great depression
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)